Arbitration awards

Case Number: PSES 377-08/09 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: N. Mhlanga
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 221-08/09 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: M.T. Coetzee
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Alleged Unfair Discrimination
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 230-08/09 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: L. Visser
  Respondent:  WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 149-08/09 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: C. Esau
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Alleged Unfair Dismissal
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 508-08/09 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: NFC. Poggenpoel 
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Respondent to appoint applicant | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 229-08/09 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: Y. Maans
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 199-08/09 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: M. Marsh
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Settlement agreement.

Case Number: PSES 285-07/08 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: N. Abrahams
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Respondent to appoint applicant | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 833-07/08 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: J. Sigudla
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 226-07/08 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: L.J. Muller
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 125-07/08 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: K. Isaacs
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 281-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: C. Dhlamini
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Alleged Overpayment
• Award / Outcome:  Respondent is to pay compensation of R90 660.03 plus all other benefits. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 148-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: J.I. Julius
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Alleged Unfair Dismissal
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 438-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: S.M. Vos
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Alleged Unfair Discrimination
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Respondent to appoint applicant. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 360-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: M.R.M. Bains & 2 Others
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 76-07/08 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: I.J. Fourie
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Incapacity Sick Leave
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 554-07/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: Koeleman & Venter
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Alleged Unfair Discrimination
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Respondent to appoint applicant. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 71-06/07 WC | PSES 72-06/07 WC | PSES 73-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: L. Mlonyeni | L. Ngwayi | M. Komane
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 249-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: M.A. Myners
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 259-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: W.C. Böhmer
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 256-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: E. Jodwana
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Alleged Unfair Dismissal
• Award / Outcome: Respondent to appoint applicant. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 202-06-07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: S Adams
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 581-05-06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: Y Basson
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 105-06-07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: L Liebenberg
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 529-05-06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: FL Williams
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 253-05-06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: CA Persence
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 87-06/07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: JJ Engelbrecht
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 118-06-07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: SA Herman
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. |  In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 2-06-07 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: CE Conradie
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 300-05/06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: EEG Pietersen
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of fixed term contract
• Award / Outcome: Respondent is to pay compensation of R 20 400,00. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 512-05/06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: DOG Muller
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Promotion
• Award / Outcome: No cost order was made. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 439-05/06WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: DA Kotze
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 281-05/06WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: F Williams
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Alleged unfair dismissal
  Sub Issue: Non-renewal of contract
• Award / Outcome: Repeat the short listing and inter-viewing process. | No cost order was made. | In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 463 05-06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: JJ Markgraaf
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Provision of benefits
• Award / Outcome: In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 390 04/05 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: ZC Molo
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 579 04/05 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: MA du Plessis
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Respondent to instruct SGB to repeat short listing and nomination process. | The appointment of the current incumbent will either be confirmed or withdrawn by the respondent. | No cost order was made.

Case Number: PSES 12 05/06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: AJ Sigudla
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: In favour of the applicant.

Case Number: PSES 178 05/06WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: ED Theron
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 243 05/06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: Windvogel
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Appointment / Promotion
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 270 05/06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: DF Claassen
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed due to applicant’s absence. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 280 05/06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: JD Prinsloo
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
• Award / Outcome: Applicant not entitled to any relief. | No cost order was made.

Case Number: PSES 282 05/06 WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: MM Mtshemla
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Dismissal in terms of Section 14(1) of the EEA
• Award / Outcome: Applicant’s dismissal in terms of section 14(1) of the EEA was both substantively and procedurally fair. | In favour of the respondent.

Case Number: PSES 254 05/06WC

• Parties Involved
  Applicant: ID Hartzentberg
  Respondent: WCED
• Nature of dispute
  Main Issue: Unfair Labour Practice
  Sub Issue: Benefits
• Award / Outcome: Application dismissed. | In favour of the respondent.